Total views : 139

Numerical and Experimental Analysis of Draft Tubes for Francis Turbine


  • Invertis University, Bareilly − 243123, Uttar Pradesh, India


Objectives: Draft tube is an important component of a hydro turbine (reaction) because it permits a negative head thereby increasing the total head on the turbine. It is located below the runner and allows deceleration of flow at exit. Since, the efficiency of the turbine can be increased by increasing the overall-efficiency of the draft tube, it's important to identify and optimize the design parameters which affect the efficiency of draft tube. Methods/ Statistical Analysis: In the present study, numerical and experimental analysis was done on different draft tubes in Francis turbine. In experimental study, different types of draft tubes were designed, fabricated and tested on a Francis turbine test rig. For conical draft tube, cone angle and cross section (outlet) was varied to understand the flow dynamics. Further, elbow draft tube (rectangular section) was also designed and tested to determine Best Efficiency Point (BEP). Numerical analysis was done using ANSYS CFX for various draft tubes which were designed in ANSYS Design Modeler. Findings/Results: The results of numerical analysis were validated experimentally. High pressure zones were identified in conical and elbow draft tube, although, overall pressure was less than atmospheric pressure. The efficiency of Francis turbine using 8 degree cone angle gives higher efficiency. For angles greater than 8 degree, backflow was observed. For variable discharge conditions (part-load), elbow draft tube can be used because of lesser variations in efficiency at different flow rates. Applications/Improvements: Further, conical draft tube with square section was also analyzed. Higher values of efficiency were obtained at higher speed of the turbine. Hence, it is advisable to further study this type of draft tube.


CFD, Draft Tubes, Efficiency, Francis Turbine, Suction Pressure.

Full Text:

 |  (PDF views: 202)


  • Key World Energy Statistics. Date accessed: 20/03/2017. Crossref.
  • Gubin MF. Draft Tubes of Hydro Electric Stations. Amerind Publishing Company Co Pvt. Ltd. India, 1973.
  • Date accessed: 20/03/2017. Crossref.
  • Khare R, Prasad V, Mittal SK. Effect of Runner Solidity on Performance of Elbow Draft Tube, Energy Procedia. 2012; 14:2054−59. Crossref.
  • Khare R, Prasad V, Verma M. Design Optimisation of Conical Draft Tube of Hydraulic Turbine, International Journal of Advances in Engineering Science and Technology. 2012 May; 2(1):21−26.
  • Jeon JH, Byeon SS, Kim YJ. Effects of Draft Tube on The Hydraulic Performance of A Francis Turbine, Materials Science and Engineering. 2013; 52:1−7. Crossref.
  • Prasad V, Khare R, Chincholikar A. Hydraulic Performance of Elbow Draft Tube for Different Geometric Configurations using CFD. IGHEM, 2010, p. 252−56. PMid: 20064539.
  • Soni V, Roghelia A, Desai J, Chauhan V. Design Development of Optimum Draft Tube for High Head Francis Turbine using CFD. Proceedings of the 37th International and 4th National Conference on Fluid Mechanics And Fluid Power, 2010, p. 1−10.
  • Duquesne P, Maciel Y, Dan Ciocan G, Deschênes C. Flow Separation in a Straight Draft Tube Particle Image Velocimetry. IOP Conference Series Earth and Environmental Science. 2014 Sep, p. 2−11.
  • Bhatt GB, Shah DB, Patel KM. Design Automation and CFD Analysis of Draft Tube for Hydro Power Plant, International Journal of Mechanical and Production Engineering. 2015; 3(6):40−43.
  • Anup KC, Lee YH, Thapa B. CFD Study on Prediction of Vortex Shedding in Draft Tube of Francis Turbine and Vortex Control Techniques, Renewable Energy. 2016; 86:1406−21. Crossref.
  • Jacob T. Evaluation Sur Modèle Réduit Et Prédiction De La Stabilité De Fonctionnement Des Turbines Francis. École Polytechnique Fédérale De Lausanne. 1993, p. 1−226.
  • Khurana S, Singh N, Singh H. Effect of Cavitations on Hydraulic Turbines- A Review, International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology. 2012; 172−77.
  • Thicke, RH. Practical Solutions for Draft Tube Instability, Water Power and Dam Construction.1981; 33(2):31−37.
  • Brekke H. A Review of some Dynamic Problems in Hydropower Plants. International Association for HydroEnvironment Engineering and Research WG1, 2003.
  • Blommaert G. Étude du Comportement Dynamique des Turbines Francis Contrôleactif de Leurstabilité de Fonctionnement. École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne. 2000, p. 1−151.
  • Resiga RS, Thi CVU, Muntean S, Ciocan GD, Nennemann B. Jet Control of the Draft Tube Vortex Rope in Francis Turbines at Partial Discharge. 23rd IAHR Symposium. 2006 Oct, 1(14). PMid:17308691.
  • Chen C, Nicolet C, Yonezawa K, Farhat M, Avellan F, Tsujimoto Y. One-Dimensional Analysis of Full Load Draft Tube Surge, Journal of Fluids Engineering. 2008; 130. Crossref.
  • Miyagi O. Cavitations in and Consequent Vibration of the Draught Tube of a Water Turbine, Journal of the Society of Mechanical Engineers Japan. 1930; 33(2):57−59.
  • Brennen CE. Bubble Dynamics Damage and Noise. Hydrodynamics of Pump. Cambridge University Press. 2011, p. 78−95. Crossref.


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.